HeRMeS-XC / Proctor test
The Proctor test: understanding the optimum water content
The Proctor test looks for the water content at which a soil compacts best. It gives two values, the optimum water content and the maximum dry density, which the site then uses as compaction references.
Why an optimum?
A dry soil compacts poorly: friction between grains resists settlement. A little water lubricates the grains and the density rises. But beyond a certain amount, the water takes the place of the grains and compaction does not expel it: the density falls again. There is therefore a water content for which, at equal compaction energy, the dry density is highest.
The principle of the test
Several samples of the same soil are prepared at increasing water contents. Each is compacted in a standard mould, with the same energy, in layers, using a rammer. For each sample, the wet density and the water content are measured, then the dry density is deduced. At least five points are needed, bracketing the optimum, with a gap of about two points of water content between successive tests.
Standard Proctor and modified Proctor
Both tests follow the same principle and differ in compaction energy, in the Proctor mould:
| Standard Proctor | Modified Proctor | |
|---|---|---|
| Rammer mass | 2,490 g | 4,535 g |
| Drop height | 305 mm | 457 mm |
| Number of layers | 3 | 5 |
With the same number of blows per layer, the energy of the modified Proctor is about 4.5 times that of the standard Proctor. The result has a distinct name: OPN for the standard Proctor optimum, OPM for the modified Proctor optimum. An OPN value is never compared with an OPM value. In practice, the standard Proctor is rather used for embankments and capping layers, the modified Proctor for pavement bases; the specification decides.
Calculating the dry density
ρd = ρh / (1 + w)
ρh is the density of the wet soil compacted in the mould (mass of wet soil divided by the volume of the mould) and w the water content, written as a decimal in this formula (10 % is written 0.10). Fictitious example, at five water contents:
| w (%) | ρh (g/cm³) | ρd (g/cm³) |
|---|---|---|
| 8 | 1.93 | 1.787 |
| 10 | 2.05 | 1.864 |
| 12 | 2.12 | 1.893 |
| 14 | 2.15 | 1.886 |
| 16 | 2.10 | 1.810 |
Plotting the curve and reading the optimum
ρd is plotted on the vertical axis and w on the horizontal axis, then a smooth curve is drawn through the points. The optimum is the peak of this curve : its water content is wOPN (or wOPM) and its dry density is ρd,OPN (or ρd,OPM). This peak is read on the plotted curve; it does not necessarily coincide with the highest measured point. In the example, the highest point is at w = 12 %, while the peak of the curve is at w ≈ 12.3 % for ρd ≈ 1.90 g/cm³.
The saturation curve, a useful check
The saturation curve gives the dry density the soil would have if all its voids were filled with water:
ρd,sat = ρw / (w + ρw / ρs)
with ρw the density of water, ρs that of the grains and w as a decimal. The test curve must stay below this curve. A point that exceeds it signals an error: water content, weighing, mould volume or assumed grain density.
What the result is used for
The optimum water content indicates the moisture at which to place the soil. The maximum dry density serves as the reference: site control compares the density obtained with that of the optimum, as a percentage, according to the specification. The CBR test, which measures bearing capacity, is readily compared with the conditions of the Proctor optimum.
Common mistakes
- Taking the highest measured point as the optimum instead of the peak of the plotted curve.
- Writing w as a percentage in the formula instead of a decimal.
- Using a wrong mould volume or tare.
- Comparing an OPN result with a requirement expressed in OPM, or the reverse.
- Settling for three points, which do not allow the peak to be found.
Standards
The test is described by standard NF P 94-093, in its 2014 version. For pavement materials, the closest reference is standard NF EN 13286-2. Consult the text of the standard for the full procedure, in particular for materials containing coarse elements.
In HeRMeS-XC
You enter your compaction points once. HeRMeS-XC plots the test curve and the saturation curve, reads the optimum at the peak of the plotted curve and carries the result into the PDF report. You remain responsible for your measurements and for signing your report.
Also read: the grading curve, D10, D30, D60, Cu and Cc. All the tests handled by HeRMeS-XC: the modules.